Lies of P contains 16 Record Locations. Collecting and playing all records unlocks the Golden Melody trophy & achievement.
Each Record allows you to play a new track at the gramophone at Hotel Krat and helps you restore Humanity should you have lied too often. You cannot earn all Records in one single playthrough! Two Records are tied to Eugénie’s story, each of which is earned by selecting a Lie or a Truth option. This means that you need a second playthrough to obtain the other Record tied to the answer you didn’t choose on your first playthrough. Additionally, some Records can only be bought from Wandering Merchants in New Game+ (not available on first playthrough). Once you own all Records, you must interact with the gramophone at Hotel Krat and play them all. You don’t need to listen to each Record in their entirety, you can just start one and immediately start the next. Below is a list of all Record locations and how to obtain them in chronological order.
Records available in First Playthrough:
Inside the House on Elysion Boulevard
- Feel: when you reach the Stargazer, continue along the rooftop until you reach a small square where you must descend a ladder. Before doing so, check your right to find a lit window with the silhouette of a woman. Talk to the woman and accept her quest to retrieve her baby. Continue through the areas until you reach Krat City Hall. After finding two swordsmen near a fountain, go up the stairs, then check the right side for an Elite enemy guarding the Broken Baby Puppet recollection item. Return the item to the weeping woman and choose “That’s a cute baby” to lie or “That’s a puppet” to tell the truth. WARNING: there are reports of this Record being obtainable only during a Lie playthrough.
St. Frangelico Cathedral Library
- Divine Service: when you first reach St. Frangelico Cathedral Library, talk to Sister Cecile in the room left of the Stargazer. Collect the Holy Mark you can fine on a table by a side room with a safe, then return to her. Now proceed to defeat Fallen Archbishop Andreus, then return to Cecile’s location to get Cecile’s Written Confession. Open the Collectibles menu (Letters) and read it.
Malum District
- Someday: can be bought from the Wandering Merchant inside the Red Lobster Inn for 3,800 Ergo. When you reach the Inn, continue until you can open a shortcut door back to the Stargazer. Face the shortcut door, then turn over and you should spot a small ladder on the right side of the room leading you to the Wandering Merchant.
Estella Opera House Entrance
- Fascination: enter the Opera House and go up the stairs on the right. Up the stairs again and past the singing spider for a small hallway leading to two doors. One of these doors can be opened to get access to a room with Adelina the Actress. Before doing anything else, check if you own the Red Apple item in your Recollection items. If not, head back to Hotel Krat and buy from Polendina for 1,000 Ergo. Now return to Adelina and when she asks for it, give her the apple. Now continue through the Opera House until you’ve defeated the King of Puppets. Then, return to Adelina’s room to be able to collect this Record from the ground. WARNING: if you don’t give Adelina the Red Apple, she won’t drop the Fascination record, making this a missable one.
Grand Exhibition Conference Room
- Quixotic: after defeating Champion Victor, continue on and you’ll eventually reunite with the Red Fox and Black Cat. Agree to give them some Gold Coin Fruit to receive this Record.
Hotel Krat
- Why: as you explore the Grand Exhibition Gallery, you’ll find Belle. Talk to her and she will join Hotel Krat after you’ve defeated Champion Victor main boss. Proceed through the story until you’ve obtained information on how to unlock the secret passageway behind Antonia’s portrait, then talk to Belle and Accept her request to look for her friend. Then, fast-travel to Krat Central Station. Go right and then down the stairs, turn around and enter the train car. Talk to the NPC to receive the collectible. Now return to Hotel Krat and talk to Belle. During the conversation, say that he died in battle to lie or say that he became a monster for the truth. To obtain this Record, you must lie to her. WARNING: this Record is missable if you attack the NPC.
Hermit’s Cave
- Misty E’rA: as you explore the cave, you’ll meet an elite Decay enemy with a shield. Kill it to obtain this Record.
Hotel Krat
- Far East Princess: after you’ve killed Alidoro in Relic of Trismegistus Combat Field, head back to Hotel Krat and ask Venigni to decrypt Alidoro’s Cryptic Vessel. Now, read the Decryption in the Collectibles menu, then talk to Eugénie. When talking to her, choose “I think he was just a talented Stalker” to obtain this Record.
Ascension Bridge
- Memory of Beach: after defeating Laxasia The Complete, return to Hotel Krat to find out Antonia has passed away. Head up into Geppetto’s Study to find this on her wheelchair. WARNING: this Record is missable if you didn’t have Giangio craft the Cure for Antonia after defeating Champion Victor. You must have Giangio craft the cure and then you must instruct Polendina to administer the cure. After doing so, talk to Antonia to find out how better she feels already.
- Shadow Flower: after defeating Laxasia The Complete, enter Sophia’s bedroom and choose “Give her peace”. Then, you can find this on the armchair in front of you after obtaining the Entreat gesture. WARNING: On my Truth playthrough, this Record didn’t spawn on the armchair. It only did in my Lie playthrough by giving Sophia peace and receiving the Entreat gesture.
New Game+ Records:
The Records below can only be obtained in the second playthrough on New Game+.
Cerasani Alley
MISSABLE
- Proposal, Flower, Wolf Part 1 (Golden): talk to the Wandering Merchant by the Cerasani Alley stargazer before the Parade Master main boss and buy the Record for 6,000 Ergo. WARNING: this Record is missable because the Wandering Merchant disappears later in the game. Buy it now.
Inside the House on Elysion Boulevard
- Quixotic (Golden): talk to the Wandering Merchant by the Inside the House on Elysion Boulevard stargazer to buy this for 10,000 Ergo.
Lorenzini Arcade
- Shadow Flower (Golden): can be bought from the Wandering Merchant you find in your path for 10,000 Ergo.
Abandoned Apartment
- Memory of Beach (Golden): can be bought from the Wandering Merchant near the Stargazer for 10,000 Ergo.
Hotel Krat
- Proposal, Flower, Wolf Part 1: after you’ve killed Alidoro in Relic of Trismegistus Combat Field, head back to Hotel Krat and ask Venigni to decrypt Alidoro’s Cryptic Vessel. Now, read the Decryption in the Collectibles menu, then talk to Eugénie. When talking to her, choose “He was Eugénie’s older brother” to obtain this Record. If you reload the area at the Stargazer, you will also unlock The Story of a Stranger Girl by talking to her again.
Rosa Isabelle Street Entrance
- Fascination (Golden): first, you must meet Test Subject 826. When you reach Arceh Abbey Outer Wall, continue to the vertical room with the two beams in the middle. At the bottom of the room, ride the elevator past the traps and talk to Test Subject 826 at the bottom to obtain this Gesture. After defeating the next main boss, you can return to Rosa Isabelle Street Entrance to find Test Subject 826. From the Stargazer, go down the stairs and then to the bottom of the street, through the shortcut gate. Continue to the bridge above Rosa Isabelle Street to find Test Subject 826 and buy the Record.
These are all the Records in Lies of P. For all other Collectibles refer to Lies of P Collectible Guide.
naoneko says
the lie/truth playthrough is kinda confusing here, the choices are sometimes interchangeable.
for sophia, “free her” does not show as when you go the lie playthrough
it shows release her or give her peace
choosing release her does not drop the records.
FranciRoosters says
You’re correct, the choices are indeed interchangeable. However, I’m confused as to what you’re actually pointing out. The latest update to this guide shows all the right answers you have to give to obtain all Records.
Allthrough says
According to this guide I have to kill Alidoro in both playthroughs in order to get the 2 records from Eugénie?Otherwise I can’t get the plat within 2 playthroughs? This is so sad. How was I supposed to know I had to kill him in Relic of Trismegistus Combat Field since he sold boss weapons I was not yet able to buy?
FranciRoosters says
Special Weapons are sold by Explorer Hugo if Alidoro is killed.
dan says
Two playthroughs now both lie and truth and still no record ” why ” from belle. Both times i got an Electric Blitz abrasive as a reward for completing the quest.
FranciRoosters says
Weird, I received this record in both runs. I wonder if this is an isolated bug at this point.
Sky says
Please mark this as missable. If you accidentally attack the infected husband you will be locked out of getting the record.
FranciRoosters says
Done
Matt pace says
Where exactly is this the why record? Struggling to find the npc
FranciRoosters says
Belle or his friend? If the former, did you talk to her at Grand Exhibition Gallery? If the former, it’s inside a train car at Krat Central Station Platform. From the Stargazer, go through the shortcut gate, down the stairs, turn around and you’ll find the open car.
JH0604 says
I need some confirmation regarding the “Why” record, I told Belle the truth and received no record. So do I have to tell her lie to get it?
FranciRoosters says
Weird, I received the Record in both runs. I’ve added a note.
Val says
For the Devine Service record if you beat the boss before giving Cecile the mark, she turns hostile, and you miss the record.
Kevin says
I never had an option to attack Alidoro on my truth NG+ playthrough. Wouldn’t let me kill him so couldn’t get the record. Not sure if it was a glitch or if you can’t kill him during a truth playthrough, it was bizarre
FranciRoosters says
You did talk to him, yes?
tot says
I did not receive the first record Feel when I spoke the truth about the little baby puppet, so you have to lie there
FranciRoosters says
Thanks, I’ve added a warning.
Daryl says
I’m on my first playthrough (a Lie playthrough) and just got my first record ‘Feel’. You mention in the description that playing the records restores Humanity if you lie too often. How will this affect my Lie playthrough? Should I just collect the records and not play them to ensure I get the correct ending?
FranciRoosters says
Correct
AHMED TALAL says
i don’t give Adelina the Red Apple and killed the puppet king
my question can i got it in my truth playthrough ?
so now i can’t get the final special weapon because i don’t have all records ?
FranciRoosters says
Yes, you can get it in NG+. You will still be able to get Golden Lie even without all Records.
Finch says
So quick question: I didn’t know that I shouldn’t have listened to the records. I listened four of them while i am on my lie playthrough. I currently am into the seventh chapter. Did I mess up the endings?
FranciRoosters says
If you’ve listened to Records before the moment I instruct you to in the guide, it’s hard to say where you are now in the imaginary Lie/Truth line.
Kotsidas says
Just a time saver tip. You don’t actually have to listen to the entire record. Just the first two seconds each until you see the auto save icon which means it has registered that you indeed have the record. I just popped the trophy like that.
FranciRoosters says
Yes, this is mentioned in the guide ?
Jiggs says
Can’t find 826 in either the abbey or Isabelle street, did he disappear since I killed laxasia before meeting him?
FranciRoosters says
He may have if you can’t find him. Whether he officially disappears after defeating Laxasia if you haven’t met him hasn’t been tested.
Riv1404 says
if you on a TRUTH run you cant kill Alidoro, i do not have this icon at all. I do not know waht to od right now
FranciRoosters says
I’m not sure how true that is, no pun intended. In my Truth run could attack him twice and kill him just like during the Lie playthrough. I wonder if this is a recurrent bug as other players have reported this. By the way, have you updated the game to 1.02? It’s just released today.
M456 says
Same thing happend for me. I think you have to hand over the gloves in chapter 7 and get the wanted poster, to make progression towards this.
Just to confirm Iam on NG+, truth, version 1.02.
Hotricesama says
For the Eugene’s records, you HAVE to kill Alidoro otherwise the game won’t allow you to kill him after traveling to Isle of the Alchemist… I screwed up on newgame++ now I’ve to go another round..
Tm says
The Fascination record can be optained during the first playthrough.
Tm says
And I didn’t get the feel record either, when I spoke the truth.
victor says
you said to save the administering the cure for the lady for your truth play through , was i supposed to do it anyway?