Broken is the 8th chapter in Detroit Become Human. This walkthrough will guide you through all the choices of the Broken level for 100% completion.
Triggers automatically after completing Stormy Night Chapter.
Flowchart (100%):
Here’s a quick overview of the 100% complete flowchart for “Broken”.
Checkpoint: After Party
- Enter Living Room: Automatic Story-related task. Upon arriving at Carl’s house, wheel him to the big living room.
- Pour Whisky: Another mandatory task, Carl will say he is “old enough to choose his own medicine” and wants a Whisky which Markus must grab from the living room.
- Check Studio Without Carl: Now you have two choices. Markus and Carl notice the lights in the Studio are on and suspect a break-in, thus calling the police. Carl wants to check it out. Either check the studio without him or bring him with you. For this just leave him in the living room.
- Check Studio With Carl: This objective requires a second playthrough – wheel Carl to the Studio, bring him with you to investigate.
- Confront Leo: Of course it’s Carl’s son who broke in to steal some art and resell it for drug money. He is very aggressive and looking for a fight. No matter what you say to him he will always start pushing Markus.
- Break Mind Palace: This is another unmissable task. After Leo pushes Markus, he has to “break a mind palace”, just press the displayed buttons.
- Markus Becomes Deviant: Also an automatic objective, after Markus breaks free from the mind palace he becomes deviant. He no longer has to listen to what other people tell him and can make his own choices.
- Obey Carl: There are two paths here leading to different endings within the chapter (but not affecting actual game endings). The first is to obey Carl and let Leo attack you –> Carl dies from heart attack. Your choice affects what magazines will spawn in ‘Waiting for Hank…’. Regardless, you will need two playthroughs for all magazines anyway so it doesn’t matter what you pick. Either way the police arrive and shoot Markus and Carl also dies one way or the other.
- Carl Dies of a Heart Attack: Automatic on the ‘Obey Carl’ path.
- Police Arrive: Automatic on the ‘Obey Carl’ path.
- Leo Accused Markus: Automatic on the ‘Obey Carl’ path.
- Push Leo: This is the second ending of the chapter and requires a replay. Markus has to attack/push Leo –> Results in Leo hitting his head and being unconscious. It looks like he’s dead but he’s only hurt and can be seen briefly in a scene at the end of the game in ‘Night of the Soul’. This affects magazine collectibles in ‘Waiting for Hank…’ but for those you require 2 playthroughs anyway. Just like the first choice, police will come and shoot Markus. With this option though, you have a chance to see Carl again at the end of the game (*thanks to Riwus for pointing it out).
- Leo is Hurt: Automatic on the ‘Push Leo’ path.
- Police Arrive: Automatic on the ‘Push Leo’ path.
- Police Mistook Markus for the Aggressor: Automatic on the ‘Push Leo’ path.
All done! The outcome of this chapter is irrelevant for how the rest of the game plays out, doesn’t matter what path you choose here. This concludes the Broken chapter.
Up Next: The Interrogation
For more Walkthroughs, check out the complete Detroit Become Human Walkthrough.
jmart says
You do see Carl again if you chose to push leo and you get a message from a reformed Leo on Carl’s answering machine.
PowerPyx says
How, Where, When? :o
I never saw him again, did 4 playthroughs. You only talk to his grave, but not him (in Night of the Soul).
Riwus says
You see Karl again if choose you to push Leo, closer to the end of the game (prior to final demonstration if i remember correctly). Marcus comes to him for advice. Player can kill him by choosing angry prompts, which cause Karl’s heart to stop. If you say that you want Peace he will say that you are good man and you leave.
PowerPyx says
Thanks, I’ve heard the same from others. I added it in and credited you.
What happened for me is that Markus only saw Carl’s grave in ‘Night of the Soul’. He went to the graveyard and Leo walked past him for a brief scene.
Nick says
Very late to this, but for trophy hunters, there are other important consequences from this chapter: you’ll get one of two trophies depending on your decision with Leo, and what you decide will determine the appearance of at least one magazine later on.
Zach says
Do you have to keep Carl alive for the survivors trophy?
Jaxx says
Nope..
Just:
Alice
Connor
Hank
Jerry
Josh
Kara
Luther
Markus
North
Simon
You don’t even have to keep the Chloe alive..
Josh says
Can you keep Marcus alive
Timothy says
Wait A Minute, So What Happens if You Just Leave Carl And Investigate?
L says
He follows you anyway.